Keeping Up With The Penguins

Reviews For The Would-Be Booklover

The Hate U Give – Angie Thomas

The Hate U Give by Angie Thomas was one of the most-frequently banned and challenged books in the year it was released, according to the American Library Association. Why? Officially, for its profanity, vulgarity, and references to drug use. But, unofficially, it’s hard to imagine that it’s for any reason other than it might stoke the fire of young would-be Black Lives Matter activists in the tinderbox that is the United States. This is a story about the human cost of racially-motivated police brutality.

This is Thomas’s debut novel, an expanded version of a short story she wrote in response to the death of Oscar Grant. It’s shelved and marketed as a young adult novel – given that it features a teen protagonist who, one could argue, “comes of age” – but The Hate U Give would be appealing and accessible to readers of all ages. We all have something to learn from this story.

It opens at a party, where our main character – Starr Carter – is feeling awkward and uncomfortable. Even though the party is thrown in her neighbourhood by people roughly her own age, she doesn’t feel like she “fits in”, mostly (it would seem) because she attends Williamson, a “white-people” high school. When shots are fired, her friend Khalil helps her escape, and they drive away to safety in his car… or so they think.

Khalil is pulled over, and after a short interaction, the police officer shoots him. Starr is the only witness to Khalil’s death. The officer keeps his gun trained on her until back-up arrives.





That might sound like a story in and of itself, but really it’s only the beginning of The Hate U Give. The story actually unfolds around what Starr decides to do next. Should she make a statement to police and prosecutors, knowing it might cause trouble for her family? Should she identify herself as the witness among her friends and neighbours, knowing that it might incite the ire of local gang members? She’s stuck between the proverbial rock and hard place, an impossible decision for anyone to make, let alone a sixteen-year-old girl. Chuck into the mix a racist frenemy, a white boyfriend who doesn’t get it, and the ripple effects of drug addiction and gang violence in her neighbourhood… Unsurprisingly, Starr struggles under the weight of what is right and what is safe.

“I’ve tweeted RIP hashtags, reblogged pictures on Tumblr, and signed every petition out there. I always said that if I saw it happen to somebody, I would have the loudest voice, making sure the world knew what went down. Now I am that person, and I’m too afraid to speak.”

The Hate U Give (38)

The Hate U Give is a call to action in the form of a young-adult novel. Its central message is reflected in its title, which is actually a reference to an idea attributed to Tupac: that THUG LIFE actually stands for “The hate u give little infants fucks everybody”. In other words, raising children – of all colours and creeds – in a racist system that only functions on the back of oppression is good for no one. Or, to borrow an older saying, we reap what we sow.





In the Author’s Note following the novel’s conclusion, Thomas describes the first time she saw a photo of Emmett Till. She managed to convince herself that it was “history”, until she saw the video of Oscar Grant. This triggered a series of difficult conversations and revelations for her, and “from all of those questions and emotions, The Hate U Give was born”. She emphasises that her motivation for writing the novel was the opportunity to give young people the reassurance that they are not alone in their frustration, fear, and sadness. I like to think that it’s not just “young people” Thomas is speaking to anymore, because surely after the events of this year (if nothing else), that frustration, fear, and sadness is felt by all.

The presence of Chris – Starr’s white boyfriend – in the novel is a deft touch, one that kindly guides white readers towards understanding the role we have to play in making change happen. The Hate U Give also serves the dual role of guidebook and mirror, with Starr’s code-switching reflecting the lived reality of many readers while revealing it to others who haven’t experienced it for themselves. Characters like Starr – and her brothers, her father, and mother – are too often caricatured in fiction. It was a relief to read such a complex and nuanced depiction of them, and the politics of their communities.

It’s both amazing and saddening that The Hate U Give is still so resonant and relevant, perhaps even more so than when it was initially published. The film adaptation – released in 2018 – has also gone on to receive popular and critical acclaim. And so I circle back around to where I began: it’s hard to imagine that this book could be banned for any reason other than systemic racism. I feel a nervous flutter in my stomach as I type that, and I’m tempted to backspace over it, but if Starr can find the strength to use her voice then so can I.

My favourite Amazon reviews of The Hate U Give:

  • “I haven’t read it yet, I’ve heard good things and I’m sure it’s great. All I know is that it came broken. Not sure who’s fault it is but I don’t know who to tell and I’m very upset.” – Alyssa
  • “I’ve been wanting to read something that could help me understand better what blacks are like. This was was a great start. I plan to read more to help me understand as I’m a 70 something women who doesn’t consider myself racist but I grew up in VA and my school was the first in our country to graduate black people from a regular formerly all white High School. I need to continue my education.” – Ruth Moorman
  • “Couldn’t read the book — the first few pages were so full of obcenities I stopped caring what the plot was about. I know some young people talk this way but I choose to avoid filling my mind with dirt.” – Lee Gardner
  • “Doesn’t contain a Y and a O in the title.
    I won’t stand for this kind of madness.” – The Biz
  • “Contacting customer service immediately.” – Amazon Customer

5 Comments

  1. I’m in the middle of reading this one right now (actually, I’m almost finished with it, about 80% done), and it is such a fantastic book. Screw the political optics surrounding this book, I think this should be required reading for any person interested in or wanting to understand the Black Lives Matter movement (even those who may identify as politically conservative, some of whom think that the slogan means that *only* Black lives should matter, which is not the point of it whatsoever). It’s targeted to young adult readers, but I’ve always felt that YA books can transcend age limits. This is really a book that should be read by people of all ages, and Angie Thomas does a fantastic job at framing the story and the message in a way that people of all ages can understand, and even though the characters in The Hate U Give are fictional, it deals with real world issues in a way that make us, the readers, develop empathy for the narrator and realize that this, and the real life stories that inspired it, is reality for a lot of Black people in America.

    I haven’t seen the movie yet, but I hear it’s good. I remember Amandla Stenberg from her role in “The Hunger Games” and she did such an amazing job as Rue.

    I don’t often give five-star reviews for books, but this one is leaning towards a five-star rating. I have a feeling that The Hate U Give could end up being considered a modern classic and Angie Thomas could someday have a reputation in African American literature up there with the likes of Alice Walker, James Baldwin, Toni Morrison, Zora Neale Hurston, Mildred D. Taylor, and so many others. Just because it’s a young adult novel doesn’t mean it should be considered a throwaway. It’s a book that goes beyond age groups.

    Heck…I should consider putting some of this in my Goodreads review once I finish! I just had to copy and paste some of this into my Notes app.

    • ShereeKUWTP

      September 30, 2020 at 10:46 AM

      You are absolutely right, Crystal – contemporary YA books, this one being a prime example, can connect and engage with readers of all ages in a particularly powerful way. You should absolutely copy/paste this comment for GR, you nailed it! 😉

  2. It’s getting to the point where it will be impossible to publish a book In USA that doesn’t attract criticism and calls for it to be punished. For a country that advocates freedom of speech ( I think but am not entirely sure it is enshrined in the Constitution) it’s astonishing.

    • ShereeKUWTP

      October 2, 2020 at 6:25 PM

      It’s truly baffling, isn’t it?

    • Yes, freedom of speech is in our Constitution. It’s one of five freedoms granted in the First Amendment (and is part of the Bill of Rights, which is collectively applied to the first ten Amendments).

      During the recent Senate Judiciary Committee hearings with Supreme Court nominee Amy Coney Barrett, Senator Ben Sasse (rhymes with “class”, he’s a Republican from Nebraska) asked her to name the five freedoms in the First Amendment, and she could only name four: freedom of speech, freedom of the press, freedom of religion (which also specifies that Congress cannot make laws establishing a state religion), freedom of assembly, and freedom to petition. That last one was the one she couldn’t name, and those last two freedoms are what gives Americans the right to protest peacefully without the threat of the government arresting them.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Share
Tweet
Pin