Keeping Up With The Penguins

Reviews For The Would-Be Booklover

My Absolute Darling – Gabriel Tallent

It took me ages to read My Absolute Darling, and even longer to write this review. I kept hoping the more I slept on it, the closer I’d come to deciding how I actually felt about this book. Even after all that sleep and all that thinking, all I can articulate is… icky. Gabriel Tallent’s divisive debut novel left me feeling icky.

My Absolute Darling - Gabriel Tallent - Keeping Up With The Penguins
Get My Absolute Darling here.
You’ll be MY absolute darling if you make a purchase through one of these affiliate links to support this site.

My Absolute Darling is a survival story of sorts. It follows Julia “Turtle” Alveston, a teenager who lives with her sociopathic father and aging grandfather in the woods. The father, Martin, is a nihilistic survivalist who has taught Turtle, since the age of six, to shoot guns, light fires, and generally make-do with the barest bones of a life. She eats raw eggs from the shell for breakfast and she knows more about the fauna growing around their remote dilapidated house than she does her vocabulary homework. That’s about all I can say about this book without providing a big, huge trigger warning – if mistreatment of children bothers you at all, you’re going to want to look away.

Martin abuses Turtle: physically, psychologically, and sexually. It’s not made exactly clear how long this has been going on, but given Turtle’s matter-of-fact acceptance of the state of play, it’s presumably quite a while. Being as emotionally and psychologically isolated as she is, Turtle doesn’t recognise her father’s behaviour as abuse; she believes it to be his natural expression of love for her, and doesn’t understand why it evokes such mixed feelings in her adolescent body and mind. Turtle’s teacher suspects abuse in the home, and does her best to investigate, but both Turtle and Martin block her at every turn.

This situation might continue indefinitely, except that Turtle befriends two teenage boys who live (relatively speaking) nearby. Her connection to these boys and sharing experiences with someone other than Martin leads her to understand that something is Very Wrong in her house.

I kept a lot of notes as I was reading My Absolute Darling, planning to outline the rest of the plot for you in detail, but it’s all so stomach-churning and awful I can’t bring myself to do it. Basically, it’s an incredibly grim, more realistic(? I guess) version of Roald Dahl’s Matilda. The preternaturally strong and gifted young girl frees herself from her abusers, exacts her revenge, and goes to live with the nice teacher who offers a safe roof over her head for the first time in her life. Only, it’s nothing like the happy ending of Matilda, because Turtle remains deeply traumatised and (physically, psychologically, and emotionally) and realises she will likely never be capable of leading a ‘normal’ life after everything she has experienced.

I’m sure in a different author’s hands, My Absolute Darling could have been an almost palatable story – but Tallent doesn’t just refuse to romanticise child abuse, he goes out of his way to turn your stomach with how repulsive it is. Martin is a monster, and if you have a skerrick of empathy your chest will tighten as you realise just how trapped Turtle is in his orbit. She’s far from the perfect victim – points to Tallent for that – but you’ll root for her regardless, all the while worrying that her resistance is futile and Martin will win in the end.

Even aside from the grim and deeply unpleasant subject matter, there were a few other things working against My Absolute Darling for me personally, as a reader. It’s kind of difficult for this Australian city girl to follow the extended passages about gun maintenance and appreciation, for instance. Also, there’s a horrible, horrible dog death that made me cry (more so than all the alcoholism and violence and rape). It’s well written and clearly Tallent is talented (c’mon, I had to say it), but this book feels like a cursed object and I don’t want it in my house anymore.

So, that’s where I ended up: feeling icky about My Absolute Darling. I’m not sure why people hold up A Little Life as the poster child for trauma porn when this book is still in print. I cannot possibly recommend it in good conscience, but I leave room for the idea that there are stronger stomachs than mine out there who might find some value in it.

Read My Absolute Darling on audiobook via Libro.fm here.

My favourite Amazon reviews of My Absolute Darling:

  • “it would be great if reviewers could stop glorifying this pedophile as an grieving husband / loving father turned cray cray after a tragedy.” – Belinda Alberts
  • “If you find gratuitous violence and nonstop psychotic gun nut behavior and sexual perversion interesting then this book is for you. It’s no masterpiece.” – Gregg Moore
  • “Endless descriptions of the flora of SoCal interspersed with sadistic violence toward children.” – Elph
  • “Triggers: Incest, Rape, Child Abuse, Violence, Unfortunate circumstances regarding animals, FOUL language” – A

1 Comment

  1. Yikes. I get the idea that some books want to be gritty, but it seems like some things are better left unwritten

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Share
Tweet
Pin