Keeping Up With The Penguins

Reviews For The Would-Be Booklover

Gone Girl – Gillian Flynn

It is nothing short of miraculous that I’ve managed to go so long – over eight years, including the release of a wildly successful film adaptation – without reading Gone Girl. It’s doubly miraculous, surely, that I managed to avoid spoilers that whole time, too. But the jig is up, and it’s time to buckle down! Gone Girl is a crime thriller/mystery novel by American writer, Gillian Flynn. It came on the crest of the wave of “psychological thrillers”. In fact, given how many copies it sold (over two million in the first year alone), how long it spent on the best-seller lists, the extent to which it has permeated the popular consciousness, we might say that Gone Girl was the typhoon that caused the wave to begin with.

Gone Girl - Gillian Flynn - Book Laid Face Up On Wooden Table - Keeping Up With The Penguins
Buy Gone Girl here.
(If you use an affiliate link from this page, I’ll earn a small commission – and if I earn enough of them, I’ll be able to finance my own fake murder, maybe… A girl’s gotta dream!)

Nick Dunne’s wife, Amy, disappears on the morning of their fifth wedding anniversary. There’s a sign of a struggle in the living room, but no other real clues as to where she’s gone. The police suspect Nick was involved somehow in her disappearance, but he swears he had nothing to do with it. That’s how Gone Girl begins.

Flynn deftly weaves in their back-story, in the form of Amy’s diary entries. Nick and Amy had a fairy tale meet-cute and courtship. They married after dating for two years, merging seamlessly into one another. But when the global financial crisis hit, they both lost their jobs (Nick as a pop-culture writer for a magazine, Amy as a personality-quiz creator).

This change in circumstance all but forced them to leave cosmopolitan New York, moving to Nick’s hometown in backwater Mississippi. There, he opened a bar with his twin sister (borrowing the last of Amy’s family money to do so), and focused on caring for his terminally ill mother and demented father. Meanwhile, Amy… did nothing much, really, until she disappeared.

Flynn has borrowed from a few different sources to put this plot together. She used her own experience of being laid off from her job as a writer for Entertainment Weekly. She has also said that she was inspired by the real-life disappearance of Laci Peterson in 2002. It’s a strange mix, but damn, it’s delicious.

Nick and Amy’s perspectives alternate throughout the novel. They describe their marriage in very different ways, each (obviously) more sympathetic to their own cause and critical of the other. Both narrators feel unsteady, unreliable, but it’s not exactly clear why… at first. Every character in Gone Girl – from the married couple to the childhood friends to the greasy lawyer – exists in a murky grey area. No one is entirely likeable or unlikeable, trustworthy or untrustworthy, hero or villain.

The “big twist” comes almost exactly half-way through. Amy isn’t who she’s been telling us she is in her diary entries. At first, the switch felt a bit jarring, too extreme to be believable. But I went with it, and stopped using “believability” as a criterion by which I gauged my enjoyment of the story. I quickly found it added a whole new dimension to an already-complex plot. Plus, it was a great subversion of the kind of “suspense” we expect from these kinds of stories. The reader is forced to change gears, from wondering whether Nick Dunne was actually involved in his wife’s disappearance and waiting for the “big twist”, to wondering where on earth the story could possibly go after the truth is revealed.

I debated long and hard whether to discuss the details of the “big twist” here on Keeping Up With The Penguins. I mean, they’ve already been discussed and debated elsewhere at length – even some publicity materials have at least alluded to them. Plus, I don’t really believe in “spoilers” (if you don’t want to know what happens in a book, what the heck are you doing here?). But in the end, I had to concede: I won’t reveal all, just on the off chance that there’s some other Keeper Upperer out there who hasn’t read Gone Girl yet and would like to someday. The reading experience will definitely be better, as it is with all thrillers, if you don’t see what’s coming.

(What I will say, for those who already know, is that I really liked the ending. That might be a controversial position, as I’ve seen other reviewers bemoan it for being “unrealistic”, but I thought it was very fitting. I really appreciated that Flynn avoided the neat-bow-around-everything approach of so many other contemporary crime thriller writers. So, there.)

I was pleasantly – if weirdly – surprised by Gone Girl. I wasn’t going to stay-up-all-night to finish it, the way the schlocky blurbs promised I would, but I was always curious to see what happened next. I was particularly impressed by the complexity of the characters, and the way that Flynn weaved intriguing, tantalising hints into the story. In the Battle Of The Girls (Gone Girl versus The Girl On The Train), this one definitely comes out on top.

The film adaptation was released in 2014, written by Flynn herself and starring Ben Affleck and Rosamund Pike. I’m actually planning to watch it – a very rare outcome, but one that should be a testament to how much I enjoyed Gone Girl. I’m also keen to read Flynn’s other books (Sharp Objects, in particular, comes highly recommended), though I worry that they couldn’t possibly “live up” now that my expectations have been elevated. But even if they don’t, at least Flynn will already have a win on her record.

My favourite Amazon reviews of Gone Girl:

  • “Too many sexual remarks that were not necessary” – Tonga
  • “This is a great book, the shipping was fast, but the book was somewhat dirty. I had to wipe off dust.” – Esmerelda
  • “I would rather read an offensively revisionist middle school history textbook from a religious private school in a red state cover to cover once a week for the rest of my life then have to read this again. So you hate yourself go ahead and give somebody money for it and insult yourself by reading it. Trash.” – DangItBobby
  • “I didn’t like what was revealed in the middle of because it should have been revealed near the end of the book. I went to Wikipedia to read a review and I shouldn’t have. The idiot who did the review disclosed the whole story of what happened in the second part of the book. When I read a mystery I want the main event to be revealed at the end of the book not in the middle” – Bruce
  • “Wife loved it.” – Jeremiah


  1. Definitely read Sharp Objects. I liked it even more than Gone Girl. Really good!

  2. I can’t read your review too closely. Lol. I’ve had this book sitting on my bookshelf over two years now! I really, really should get to it finally.

    • ShereeKUWTP

      October 14, 2020 at 5:14 PM

      I did my best to keep everything vague, in the event that it turned out I wasn’t the only one who hadn’t read it yet! Get to it soon, Nina, if you can, I’d love to hear what you think! 😉

  3. Gone Girl has been sitting on my shelf for forever. I was waiting for all the hype to die down and then time and more books seem to get away with me. I’m still eager to read it. I also have Sharp Objects on my bookshelf.

    • ShereeKUWTP

      October 15, 2020 at 10:54 AM

      I do the same with big-hype books! I set it aside and think I’ll just wait ’til the dust settles… then it’s eight years later and I go “Oh, that’s right, I never read that!” hahaha.

  4. I really enjoyed Gone Girl and I liked the ending, too! But I am sick of every other thriller touted as “The Next Gone Girl!” Either that, or “The Next Girl on the Train!” lol. Move along, please.

    Although I liked GG, I haven’t read anything else by Flynn. If I remember right, the premises for a couple of her other novels sounded like there was some child abuse? Which is not something I like to read about. So if you read anything else by Flynn, let us know how dark they are in terms of dark issues.

    • ShereeKUWTP

      October 15, 2020 at 5:27 PM

      Will do, Elsie! And I’m with you, “the next Gone Girl” is the most over-used phrase in thriller marketing these past few years 😅

  5. Wow, I’m just as you described yourself until recently. I’ve resisted reading or watching Gone Girl for some reason. I don’t know whether all the hype bothered me as it sometimes does, but I’m hazy about the plot, except for the bare bones you’ve outlined here. And you’ve made me curious to read it after all. It’s great when a book lives up to its great reputation.

    • ShereeKUWTP

      October 17, 2020 at 5:04 PM

      Nothing wrong with letting the hype die down before you give it a go 😉 Would love to hear what you think as always, Paula. I think it helped that I went into it with quite low expectations (The Girl On The Train was so-so at best for me, and I figured this would be more of the same), so it was easier to clear a low bar.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *