TV scriptwriter Sally Milz is “a misanthrope from Missouri” – a cynical, divorced, 36 year old who no longer believes in love. It seems like a stock standard character on which to base a Romantic Comedy, especially when she’s paired with earnest and wealthy pop idol Noah Brewster. But Curtis Sittenfeld has a few literary tricks up her sleeve to turn this generic conceit into a captivating read.

(And it will be so romantic if you use an affiliate link to make a purchase that supports this site)
Part One of Romantic Comedy is set in 2018, on the set of The Night Owls (or TNO) – a weekly late-night New York sketch comedy show very clearly based on the real-life Saturday Night Live (as Sittenfeld herself acknowledges in her Author’s Note was a major source of inspiration). Even aside from the burgeoning romance plot, this section offers a fascinating insight into the rhythm of a TV writer’s life – from pitch meetings, to all-night re-writes, to live broadcast, to after-parties (and after-after parties). It’s not hard to see why Sally’s romantic life is reduced to occasional hook-ups with a financial analyst she doesn’t like very much when we meet her.
Noah is introduced as a celebrity host-slash-musical guest, game for just about anything the writers are keen to throw at him – even Sally’s idea for a sketch about Average Joe men who date bombshell women, and why it’s practically illegal for the roles to be reversed. After all, there’s no way a gorgeous, charismatic superstar like Noah could fall in love with a plain Jane like Sally… is there?
Throughout this first section, Romantic Comedy has strong 30 Rock vibes: think Amy Poehler, Nora Ephron, Anita Loos.
Then, in Part Two, we skip ahead a couple of years to the peak of the COVID-19 pandemic. Sally and Noah didn’t part on the best terms at the end of his stint hosting TNO, but in the lost and lonely days of lockdown, they resurrect their connection via email – Noah from his mansion in Los Angeles, Sally from her stepfather’s house in Kansas City.
Through this epistolary interlude, we see their romance blossom, and it’s where Romantic Comedy really shines. Even without any narration beyond what they put in their emails to each other, Sittenfeld manages to impress upon the reader each lead’s natural foils, and their nervousness in the delicate dance of acquaintance becoming romantic. There’s banter, there’s revelations, there’s misunderstandings, all of it eventually leading to the suggestion that they take their conversation offline and meet up IRL. Sally jumps in a borrowed car and drives 1,600 miles (even though Noah chivalrously offers to send her a private plane), just to see if her life could really turn into a romantic comedy.
Her arrival in LA might be where most rom-coms would end, but Sittenfeld takes us beyond their passionate consummation to interrogate what it really takes to build a happily ever after out of two very different lives and worldviews. It’s the perfect blend of fantasy and realism, a sexy connection with a wealthy dreamboat that takes hard work and sustained effort to maintain. Unironically, I’d happily call Romantic Comedy the perfect contemporary rom-com – it’s sensitive, self-aware, fun, and funny. I highly recommend it if you’re looking for a love story that doesn’t insult your intelligence or require massive reserves of credulity.
Read Romantic Comedy on audiobook via Libro.fm here.
My favourite Amazon reviews of Romantic Comedy:
- “This book even had the nerve to call itself “Romantic Comedy,” despite being the least romantic or funny book I have read.” – Emilie Christine
- “In the make believe world of story telling, even a woke snowflake can have love (however undeserving) drop into her lap.” – Margaret Lee









